Only 2 batons make our cut, both ASP, and the ASP Protector Friction Loc 16" is the one to buy if your state allows it.
2 products compared on one public formula, prices read on November 16, 2026. Some links are affiliate links: they never change the order. FTC disclosure.
Batons are the most restricted product family on this site, and the one with the least distance: a 16 in steel shaft keeps someone about an arm and a half away. They never need charging or refilling, which is why some people keep one in the car.
We list only two, both ASP, sold through The Home Security Superstore at listed prices. Before you buy, read your state's rule: New York's Penal Law lists the "billy", Florida counts it as a weapon for concealed carry, and California's ban has been challenged in court. If any of that applies to you, a pepper gel is the easier choice.
It depends on the state, and often on how you carry it. New York lists the "billy" among banned weapons, Florida treats it as a weapon for concealed carry, and California's statute is under challenge. Check the box on this page and your state code.
How do you close an ASP friction-loc baton?
By tapping the tip firmly on a hard surface so the friction lock lets go. The ASP Talon closes by pressing a button instead.
Is a baton better than pepper spray?
For most people, no: spray works from about 12 ft, needs no strength and is legal in more places. A baton never runs out or expires.
ASP Protector Friction Loc 16"ASP Protector 16"7.6/10$105checked Nov 16, 2026