Prices checked Nov 16, 2026 · Scores from a public formula // Is it legal in your state? →

How we score

One formula for every product, written down here, so you can check any score on the site.

Every score on Self-Defense Weapon comes from the same formula. It runs on the data in our product file: the brand's own figures (or the linked seller's, when we say so) and the US price we read on the date shown, November 16, 2026 for this edition. Our scores are built from published figures, dated prices and the sellers' own pages, not from our own measurements. No brand pays for a place, and affiliate programs never enter the formula: a product without any program can rank first, and several do.

The 9 criteria and their weights

CriterionWeight
Distance it lets you keep (brand range, family default for contact devices and alarms)20%
What it does once someone is close (family default)15%
Easy to use under stress (how it works, laser, light, warning, keychain)10%
Cost of one reload or replacement (dated)15%
Price at the linked seller (dated)10%
Tries before a reload or recharge10%
Protection from an accidental discharge10%
Warranty and replacement guarantee5%
States the seller ships to5%

A criterion the brand doesn't publish scores 2/10: we can't give credit for what isn't stated. A product needs at least 5 stated criteria and a published price to be scored at all.

How each criterion is scored

  • Distance it lets you keep (20%). By the brand's stated range in feet: 10 ft → 7.2, 12 ft → 7.6, 15 ft → 8.4, 60 ft → 9.4, 150 ft → 10. Contact devices score 3, batons 3.5 (their own length), alarms and silent alerts 5: they keep no one away, but they call for help.
  • What it does once someone is close (15%). A family value from what each family's brands publish: TASER energy devices 9, pepper sprays and gels 8, pepper-ball launchers 7.5, contact stun guns 6, alarms 5, batons 3. Contact stun guns get +1 when the brand publishes 4 µC or more and −1 at 1.6 µC or less. Volts are ignored, on purpose: they describe the spark you see and hear, not the charge delivered (TASER itself calls 1.6 µC or less "noisy but less effective").
  • Easy to use under stress (10%). A base by how it works (alarm 8, spray 6.5, TASER device or launcher 6, stun gun 5.5, baton 4), plus 1.5 for a laser, 1 for a built-in light, 0.5 for a warning arc, siren or strobe and 0.5 for keychain carry, capped at 10.
  • Cost of one reload (15%). A cartridge, five projectiles plus CO2, a new canister or a month of a paid plan, at the brand or the linked seller: $0 → 10, $10 → 8.6, $15 → 8.2, $25 → 7.4, $30 → 6.4, $45 → 5, $90 → 3.
  • Price (10%). At the linked seller, on the date shown: $10 → 10, $30 → 9, $100 → 7.5, $200 → 6.5, $400 → 5.5, $600 → 4.8, $1,700 → 2.
  • Tries before a reload (10%). Rechargeable or reusable devices score 9; otherwise by shots or bursts: 1 → 4, 2 → 6, 5 → 7.6, 7 → 8.2, 20 → 8.8, 26 → 9.
  • Protection from an accidental discharge (10%). 9 when the brand names a safety switch, flip-top, twist-lock or disable pin; 5 when it names none.
  • Warranty (5%). In years (lifetime counts as 10): 1 yr → 6, 2 yr → 7.5, 10 yr → 9.5, plus 1.5 for a replacement guarantee such as TASER's Safe Escape.
  • States the seller ships to (5%). By the number of states and DC the seller's own page excludes: 0 → 10, 1 → 9.2, 2 → 8.6, 4 → 7.6, 6 → 6.6, 11 → 4.

From the weighted average to the score you see

The weighted average of the nine criteria is put on our editorial scale: score = 7.5 + 0.76 × (weighted average − 5.27), rounded to one decimal and kept between 7.5 and 9.6. Labels: Excellent from 9.0, Very good from 8.5, Good from 8.0, Fair below.

Tie-break: no two products share a score

Products are ordered by their weighted average, then the lower price, then the longer warranty, then alphabetically. When a product would show the same score as the one just above it (or a higher one), it gets 0.1 less. If that pushes the last ones under 7.5, they are lifted back from the bottom in the same order. The order of every ranking is the formula's order; nothing is moved by hand.

Different families, one formula

A pepper gel, a stun gun and a pepper-ball launcher do different jobs, so every list says which family each product belongs to, and the family rankings only compare products of one family. The overall ranking on the home page mixes them on purpose, labelled, because that is the question most buyers start with: "what should I get?"

Prices, stock and state rules

Prices are read on the seller's US product page on the date shown next to them, in US dollars, and never taken from Amazon. Stock is checked on the same page ("add to cart" against "sold out"). The states a seller won't ship to come from its own product or shipping page. State rules come from statutes, state police pages and court libraries, with the date we read them; see laws by state. Nothing on this site is legal advice.

Every product and its score

ProductFamilyScorePrice read
SABRE Red Pepper Gel, official product photoSABRE Red Pepper GelPepper spray / gel9.6/10$9.99, Nov 16, 2026
POM Pepper Spray (Key), official product photoPOM Pepper Spray (Key)Pepper spray / gel9.5/10$14.95, Nov 16, 2026
She's Birdie 3.0, official product photoShe's Birdie 3.0Personal alarm9.4/10$34.95, Nov 16, 2026
Fox Labs Five Point Three, official product photoFox Labs Five Point ThreePepper spray / gel9.3/10$24.99, Nov 16, 2026
Byrna LE, official product photoByrna LEPepper-ball launcher9.2/10$499.99, Nov 16, 2026
Byrna SD, official product photoByrna SDPepper-ball launcher9.1/10$399.99, Nov 16, 2026
invisaWear Safety Charm, official product photoinvisaWear Safety CharmPersonal alarm9.0/10$49, Nov 16, 2026
TASER Pulse 2, official product photoTASER Pulse 2TASER device8.9/10$399.99, Nov 16, 2026
TASER Bolt 2, official product photoTASER Bolt 2TASER device8.8/10$449.99, Nov 16, 2026
Guard Dog Hornet, official product photoGuard Dog HornetStun gun8.7/10$19.99, Nov 16, 2026
PepperBall TCP, official product photoPepperBall TCPPepper-ball launcher8.6/10$329.95, Nov 16, 2026
Damsel in Defense Little Ringer, official product photoDamsel in Defense Little RingerStun gun8.5/10$84, Nov 16, 2026
Byrna CL, official product photoByrna CLPepper-ball launcher8.4/10$549.99, Nov 16, 2026
SABRE Home Defense Launcher, official product photoSABRE Home Defense LauncherPepper-ball launcher8.3/10$179.99, Nov 16, 2026
Vipertek VTS-989, official product photoVipertek VTS-989Stun gun8.2/10$27.99, Nov 16, 2026
TASER StrikeLight 2, official product photoTASER StrikeLight 2Stun gun8.1/10$169.99, Nov 16, 2026
SABRE 2-in-1 Stun Gun & Flashlight, official product photoSABRE 2-in-1 Stun Gun & FlashlightStun gun8.0/10$29.99, Nov 16, 2026
TASER 7 CQ, official product photoTASER 7 CQTASER device7.9/10$1,699.99, Nov 16, 2026
Byrna CL-XL, official product photoByrna CL-XLPepper-ball launcher7.8/10$579.99, Nov 16, 2026
SABRE Personal Alarm with LED, official product photoSABRE Personal Alarm with LEDPersonal alarm7.7/10$14.99, Nov 16, 2026
ASP Protector Friction Loc 16", official product photoASP Protector Friction Loc 16"Expandable baton7.6/10$105, Nov 16, 2026
ASP Talon Infinity 24", official product photoASP Talon Infinity 24"Expandable baton7.5/10$257, Nov 16, 2026

Found a figure that changed? Write to contact@self-defense-weapon.com and we'll correct it with the date.