Compare self-defense weapons side by side
Pick up to three: same rows for every product, the brand's own figures, the price we read on November 16, 2026.
| Product | SABRE Red Pepper Gel9.6/10$9.99checked Nov 16, 2026 | POM Pepper Spray (Key)9.5/10$14.95checked Nov 16, 2026 | She's Birdie 3.09.4/10$34.95checked Nov 16, 2026 | Fox Labs Five Point Three9.3/10$24.99checked Nov 16, 2026 | Byrna LE9.2/10$499.99checked Nov 16, 2026 | Byrna SD9.1/10$399.99checked Nov 16, 2026 | invisaWear Safety Charm9.0/10$49checked Nov 16, 2026 | TASER Pulse 28.9/10$399.99checked Nov 16, 2026 | TASER Bolt 28.8/10$449.99checked Nov 16, 2026 | Guard Dog Hornet8.7/10$19.99checked Nov 16, 2026 | PepperBall TCP8.6/10$329.95checked Nov 16, 2026 | Damsel in Defense Little Ringer8.5/10$84checked Nov 16, 2026 | Byrna CL8.4/10$549.99checked Nov 16, 2026 | SABRE Home Defense Launcher8.3/10$179.99checked Nov 16, 2026 | Vipertek VTS-9898.2/10$27.99checked Nov 16, 2026 | TASER StrikeLight 28.1/10$169.99checked Nov 16, 2026 | SABRE 2-in-1 Stun Gun & Flashlight8.0/10$29.99checked Nov 16, 2026 | TASER 7 CQ7.9/10$1,699.99checked Nov 16, 2026 | Byrna CL-XL7.8/10$579.99checked Nov 16, 2026 | SABRE Personal Alarm with LED7.7/10$14.99checked Nov 16, 2026 | ASP Protector Friction Loc 16"7.6/10$105checked Nov 16, 2026 | ASP Talon Infinity 24"7.5/10$257checked Nov 16, 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Family | Pepper spray / gel | Pepper spray / gel | Personal alarm | Pepper spray / gel | Pepper-ball launcher | Pepper-ball launcher | Personal alarm | TASER device | TASER device | Stun gun | Pepper-ball launcher | Stun gun | Pepper-ball launcher | Pepper-ball launcher | Stun gun | Stun gun | Stun gun | TASER device | Pepper-ball launcher | Personal alarm | Expandable baton | Expandable baton |
| Reach | 12 ft (SABRE) | 12 ft (POM) | Calls for help (no range) | 15 ft (Fox Labs) | 60 ft (Byrna) | 60 ft (Byrna) | Calls for help (no range) | 15 ft (TASER) | 15 ft (TASER) | Contact only | 150 ft (PepperBall) | Contact only | 60 ft (Byrna) | 60 ft (SABRE) | Contact only | Contact only | Contact only | 12 ft (TASER) | 60 ft (Byrna) | Calls for help (no range) | Its own length | Its own length |
| Shots or bursts | 13 seconds of total spray time (SABRE), about 26 half-second bursts | Up to 20 bursts (POM), ½ oz | Siren and strobe as often as you need, rechargeable | 18 half-second bursts (HSS listing) | 5-round magazine (2 in the kit); about 17 shots per 12 g CO2 (Byrna) | 5-round magazine (2 in the kit); about 22 shots per 8 g CO2 (Byrna, at room temperature) | Silent alert as often as needed; the Safety Plan is what connects it to agents | 1 shot per cartridge, then contact stun | 1 shot per cartridge, then contact stun | Contact stun, rechargeable | 6-round magazine (2 magazines in the kit) | Contact stun, rechargeable | 5-round magazine (2 in the kit); about 15 shots per 8 g CO2 (Byrna) | 7 pepper projectiles per magazine (1 magazine in the kit) | Contact stun, rechargeable | Contact stun, as many times as the battery allows | Contact stun, rechargeable | 2 shots without reloading (backup shot), then contact stun | 7-round magazine; about 17 shots per 12 g CO2 (Byrna) | Pull the chain to sound it, push the pin back to stop; reusable | Reusable, nothing to reload | Reusable |
| Power, as the brand states it | SABRE: maximum-strength formula, HPLC lab-tested, UV marking dye, sprays up to 12 ft as a gel stream. | POM: 2.12 million SHU, 1.40% major capsaicinoids, lab-tested batch by batch, stream up to 12 ft. | She's Birdie: 130 dB siren plus a flashing strobe. | Fox Labs: 2% OC at 5.3 million SHU, oil-based, UV marking dye. | Byrna: .68 caliber, 330 fps, 15.2 joules, accurate up to 60 ft. | Byrna: .68 caliber, 280 fps, 10.9 joules, accurate up to 60 ft. | invisaWear: double-click the hidden button to text your contacts your live location; with the plan, ADT agents can send first responders. | TASER publishes no voltage for the Pulse 2. It says a probe hit causes up to 30 seconds of "NMI" (its term for a full-body muscle lock), time meant for you to get away. | TASER publishes no voltage for the Bolt 2. It says a probe hit causes up to 30 seconds of "NMI" (its term for a full-body muscle lock), time meant for you to get away. | Guard Dog publishes no voltage or microcoulomb figure for the Hornet on the page we read. | PepperBall: .68 caliber, 260 fps out of the box (adjustable to 300), up to 150 ft with VXR projectiles. | Damsel in Defense rates it at 1.3 µC. | Byrna: .61 caliber, 400 fps, 12 joules, effective range 60 ft. | SABRE: .68 caliber, up to 350 fps, direct impact up to 60 ft; on hard surfaces the projectiles burst into a pepper cloud up to 6 ft wide. | The Vipertek page we read gives no voltage or microcoulomb figure for the VTS-989. | TASER says 20 kV and 10 µC, and calls cheap stun guns "noisy but less effective" at 1.6 µC or less. | SABRE rates it at 4.20 µC and says its stun guns are independently tested; it publishes no voltage for this model. | TASER does not publish a voltage. It describes a 5-second cycle and a close-range (12 ft) cartridge. | Byrna: .61 caliber, 410 fps, 12.1 joules, effective range 60 ft. | SABRE: 130 dB, audible up to 1,250 ft (381 m). | No power figure: a baton extends your reach by its length (16 in open). | No power figure: 24 in open. |
| One reload or refill | Replace the whole unit: $9.99 | Replace the unit: $14.95 (inert water practice units $7) | Nothing to buy: USB-C rechargeable | Replace the unit | 5 Byrna .68 pepper projectiles $24.99 (HSS), plus a 12 g CO2 (price not read) | 5 Byrna pepper projectiles $24.99 (HSS) plus one 8 g CO2 ($19.99 for 10 at byrna.com) | Safety Plan $14.99/month, required for 24/7 agents and emergency dispatch | Self-Defense Cartridges: $59.99 for 2 at taser.com, so $30 a shot | Self-Defense Cartridges: $59.99 for 2 at taser.com (the Pulse cartridges fit the Bolt 2) | Nothing to reload: built-in rechargeable battery, charger included | Live projectiles sold in packs; the per-round price was not on the page we read | Nothing to reload | 5 Byrna .61 pepper projectiles $24.99 (HSS) plus one 8 g CO2 ($19.99 for 10) | Pepper projectiles sold separately (price not read); 35 inert practice rounds $39.99, spare magazine $34.99 at sabrered.com | Nothing to reload: recharge cord plugs into a wall outlet (included) | Nothing to reload: USB-C recharge (charger block not included) | Nothing to reload: USB-C rechargeable battery | Two-pack of live TASER 7 CQ cartridges: $89.99 at taser.com | Projectiles and 12 g CO2 sold separately | Batteries included, not rechargeable (replacement cost not stated) | Nothing to reload | Nothing to reload |
| Light / laser / alarm | none | none | light, warning sound or arc | none | none | none | none | laser | laser | light | none | light, warning sound or arc | none | none | light | light, warning sound or arc | light | light, laser, warning sound or arc | none | light, warning sound or arc | none | none |
| Safety against misfires | Yes (named by the brand) | Yes (named by the brand) | Yes (named by the brand) | None named by the brand | Yes (named by the brand) | Yes (named by the brand) | Yes (named by the brand) | None named by the brand | None named by the brand | None named by the brand | Yes (named by the brand) | Yes (named by the brand) | None named by the brand | Yes (named by the brand) | Yes (named by the brand) | None named by the brand | None named by the brand | None named by the brand | None named by the brand | None named by the brand | None named by the brand | None named by the brand |
| Weight | 3.4 oz | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | 8 oz | 8.4 oz | 1.9 oz | 27.4 oz | 3.2 oz | Not stated | 39 oz | Not stated | 10.6 oz | 1.9 oz | 9.6 oz | Not stated | 1.6 oz | 6.7 oz | Not stated |
| Warranty | SABRE covers its sprays against defects until the expiration date, and offers a free replacement if you register within 31 days | No warranty term on the pages we read; expiration date printed on the canister | No warranty term on the product page; 30-day returns on resaleable items | Not stated on the pages we read | Warranty registration offered; the term was not on the pages we could load | Warranty registration offered; the term was not on the pages we could load | Not stated on the product page | 1-year Axon limited warranty on the device and cartridges, plus the Safe Escape replacement guarantee: if you deploy it in self-defense and leave it behind, Axon replaces it | 1-year Axon limited warranty on device and cartridges, plus the Safe Escape replacement guarantee | Guard Dog lifetime warranty if you register within 30 days of purchase | 1-year PepperBall warranty | Damsel in Defense lifetime warranty on defects in workmanship and materials | Warranty registration offered; the term was not on the pages we could load | 2-year SABRE warranty on defects; register within 90 days | No warranty term on the product page we read | 1-year Axon limited warranty, plus Safe Escape replacement if you leave it behind after using it in self-defense | 2-year SABRE warranty on manufacturing defects; registration within 90 days required | 1-year Axon limited warranty on device and cartridges | Term not on the pages we could load | 1-year SABRE limited warranty on alarms | Lifetime manufacturer warranty (HSS listing) | Lifetime manufacturer's warranty (HSS listing) |
| Seller does not ship to | Alaska, Hawaii, Massachusetts, New York | Massachusetts, New York, Washington, DC, Alaska, Hawaii | No state excluded | Alaska, Hawaii | Hawaii, Washington, DC | Hawaii, Washington, DC | No state excluded | Hawaii | Hawaii | Rhode Island | California, Washington, DC, New York, Massachusetts | Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Rhode Island | Hawaii, Washington, DC | Alaska, California, Connecticut, Washington, DC, Delaware, Hawaii, Massachusetts, Michigan, North Carolina, New Jersey, New York | Hawaii, Massachusetts, Michigan, Rhode Island, Wisconsin, Washington, DC | Hawaii, Michigan | Alaska, Connecticut, Washington, DC, Florida, Hawaii, Illinois, Massachusetts, Michigan, Mississippi, New York, Rhode Island | Hawaii | Hawaii, Washington, DC | Alaska, Hawaii | Not stated on the listing | Not stated on the listing |
| Minimum age | 18 for pepper spray in the states that set an age (see your state) | 18 for pepper spray in the states that set an age (see your state) | No age limit | Fox Labs: you must be 18 or older to carry pepper spray | Byrna sells only to buyers 18 and over | Byrna sells only to buyers 18 and over | No age limit (a phone and the app are needed) | 18 in most states; 21 in CT, HI, IL, MA, MI and PR; 19 in AR (TASER's state table) | 18 in most states; 21 in CT, HI, IL, MA, MI and PR; 19 in AR (TASER's state table) | Not stated on the product page; state minimums apply | Not stated on the product page; "check state requirements before projectile purchase" | Not stated; state minimums apply | Byrna sells only to buyers 18 and over | Not stated on the product page | Not stated on the product page; state minimums apply | 18 in most states; 21 in CT, HI, IL, MA, PR (TASER's state table); not permitted in Michigan | Not stated on the product page; state minimums apply | 18 in most states; 21 in CT, HI, IL, MA, MI and PR; 19 in AR (TASER's state table) | Byrna sells only to buyers 18 and over | No age limit | Not stated; several states restrict batons | Not stated; several states restrict batons |
| Price | Check price at SABRE | Check price at POM | Check price at She's Birdie | Check price at Fox Labs | Check price at Byrna | Check price at Byrna | Check price at invisaWear | Check price at TASER | Check price at TASER | Check price at Guard Dog | Check price at PepperBall | Check price at Damsel in Defense | Check price at Byrna | Check price at SABRE | Check price at Vipertek | Check price at TASER | Check price at SABRE | Check price at TASER | Check price at Byrna | Check price at SABRE | Check price at Home Security Superstore | Check price at Home Security Superstore |
Brand figures, read on November 16, 2026. Scores from one public formula. Some links are affiliate links; they never change a score (FTC disclosure). Laws differ by state: check yours.
Popular comparisons
Comparison tool: questions
How do I compare two products from different families?
Pick them in the boxes above: the table shows the same rows for every product. Remember that a spray, a stun gun and a launcher do different jobs; the "Reach" row is the one that tells them apart.
Which one is the best value?
The tool marks the best score of the products you picked, and the lowest price. Our score already weighs price and the cost of each reload, so the best score is usually the best value for the job.
Where do the figures come from?
From each brand's own pages (or the linked seller's when we say so), read on November 16, 2026. Scores come from our public formula, explained on the methodology page.
SABRE Red Pepper Gel
POM Pepper Spray (Key)
She's Birdie 3.0
Fox Labs Five Point Three
Byrna LE
Byrna SD
invisaWear Safety Charm
TASER Pulse 2
TASER Bolt 2
Guard Dog Hornet
PepperBall TCP
Damsel in Defense Little Ringer
Byrna CL
SABRE Home Defense Launcher
Vipertek VTS-989
TASER StrikeLight 2
SABRE 2-in-1 Stun Gun & Flashlight
TASER 7 CQ
Byrna CL-XL
SABRE Personal Alarm with LED
ASP Protector Friction Loc 16"
ASP Talon Infinity 24"